Parts Cleaning Magazine
"The Magazine for Industrial Metal Cleaning"
Case Study: Boat Maker Discovers Ultrafiltration
by: Andy Hagg
Pages: 17; October, 1999
Outboard Marine Corp (OMC) is a manufacturer
of boat brands such as Seaswirl, Lowe, and Javelin, as well as engine
brands such as Johnson Outboards and Evinrude. The company' s Waukegan,
Illinois, division is a die casting facility that forms many of the
aluminum components, from large engine blocks to small parts, for OMC'
s engine division.
Like any other manufacturing operation, OMC
Waukegan's die casting process requires cleaning of equipment. The
dies, for example, are coated with lubricants that act as release agents,
and these lubricants must be washed off after use. A cleaning stage
is also necessary whenever a die is changed on a machine, as it is for
any routine maintenance done on the equipment.
The cleaning method used by the facility is
power washing with an aqueous cleaning agent with
a pH less than 12.5 to a visible level of cleanliness. The cleaning
results in a waste effluent of agent, water, and a combination of floating
and emulsified oils. Though this waste is non-hazardous, the cost of
hauling it away was very expensive because of the high volume of water,
about 300,000 gallons per year. Therefore, OMC Waukegan sought
to find a way to recycle some of that water for reuse in their operation.
Finalists for the Governor' s Award for a pilot
study they did in conjunction with the state of Illinois, Waukegan was
offered a grant from the state to look at evaporation technologies,
ultrafiltration, and vapor recompression as methods for recycling their
wastewater. Their findings pointed to ultrafiltration as a better payback
in this application, with lower operation and maintenance costs, energy
costs, and capital investment required.
Waukegan put these findings into practice with
an Arbortech Corp (McHenry, Illinois) ultrafiltration system. The system
was a success, reducing the plant' s yearly disposal of the soap and
water cleaning solution from the 300,000 gallons previously hauled away
to 50,000 gallons. This 83% recovery naturally spared the company great
expense when hauling away their effluent. Anthony Montemurro of Waukegan
said of the process change, "It works really well, and we've been doing
it now for a couple years with significant reduction in cost."
Though they were only seeking to reuse their
water, Waukegan found an added benefit in using the ultrafiltration
system. They discovered that the membrane allows a lot of the cleaner
to pass through, reducing the amount of cleaning agent they need to
add to get their cleaner concentration back up to operating levels.
Said Montemurro, "That was something we really hadn't bargained for,
but of course, we weren't going to complain about it!"
The high rate of recovery from Waukegan's waste
stream didn't particularly surprise Arbortech' s Ray Graffia, Jr. "In
general terms," he noted, "with alkaline cleaners or phosphatizing degreasing
solutions . . . you get some recovery of the cleaner that's involved."
According to Graffia, that could be anywhere from 50% to 80% cleaner
recoverability, and any components that are lost in the process can
be made up with an additive package.
In optimal conditions at the OMC Waukegan site,
the membranes are being cleaned from once a week to once every other
week with hot water and a special cleaner. "Basically," explains Graffia,
"they turn the system off the process, do a short flush, and then they
turn it on the cleaning process." Furthermore, if a need arises for
temporary maintenance between scheduled cleanings, the 1-inch-diameter
internal dimension of the membranes allows them to be manually cleaned.
Copyright 1999, Witter Publishing Corporation
84 Park Avenue · Flemington, NJ 08822
Phone: 908-788-0343 · Fax: 908-788-3782
|